Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I've once been in that situation where the company tried to introduce a contract rewrite with the standard lack of clarity over whether it applied to everything, including outside work (e.g. open source contributions). There were enough open source developers in the company that this was a big problem.

So we all just refused to sign the contract change.

The situation stalled for a few months, and they eventually backed down and wrote in a clarification. This was the UK, so we actually had rights and couldn't just be arbitrarily sacked, and everyone was aware that pursuing individuals over this would lead to a mass exodus and the destruction of the company.



That's the effect of unionizing, that is, sticking together.


Collective bargaining, indeed! A union is merely this formalised.


In the UK, you can't legally get fired without cause, regardless of being in a union or not. (You can be made redundant but shrug).


And if they hire someone else to do your job, that wasn't redundancy, that was firing under false pretenses, and you can sue.


Not signing a new contract in the UK is not as protected as you think here. Unless TUPE applies where there are protections


Not protected in the formal sense, but the old one still applied with its month's notice in both directions. Really the key factor was the difficulty in replacing developers.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: