Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It is worth noting that the Minds are not perfect. They have God-like faculties but are still flawed beings.

The Culture can create perfect Minds, but they tend to be born, look around, and instantly sublime away to some other, perhaps more interesting, dimensions.

Without these personality 'defects', the Minds are not really interested in this universe or humans at all.

This opens enough gaps to still present the Minds as interesting characters in several of his novels.



I did say that the minds are gods compared to us. What I was trying (somewhat clumsily) to convey is that the minds can think many times faster than us and can partition sections of themselves in order to multi-task on a stupendous scale. I think even for a talented author like Banks it would be a struggle to write an entire novel from the perspective of such beings because it would be a struggle to imagine what it must be like to be so powerful.

From that perspective it's not entirely implausible to write a 1000 page novel that takes place within 10 minutes of human time :-)


From my recollection, this sort of thing is conveyed in Banks' novels. The minds (expecially ones attached to warships or General Systems Vehicles) can see the entire state of the local universe around them. It's as if we were looking at a flatland universe. They can see the thoughts forming in your head if they wish. But this of thing is mostly constrained by convention not ability.

It is seen as the height of rudeness to do this rather than listen to someone speak.

A Mind in one novel who does not abide by this rule is known as "Meatfucker" by the other minds.

One of his books, Excession, contains lots of inter-mind conversations. They are presented in the book in a similar way to emails with headers. These include timestamps, and some are very fast (for a lot of text).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: